Tracking Housing Shortages Based on Q4 - 2024

Brandon Keen • February 20, 2025

Housing Shortages and How They're Affecting the USA Real Estate Market

The National Association of REALTORS® (NAR) has been tracking housing shortages across major metropolitan areas using its quarterly Housing Shortage Tracker index. This index measures the number of new building permits issued relative to job growth, helping to identify regions where housing supply lags behind demand. A higher index indicates that job creation is outpacing home construction. Historically, one single-family home permit has been issued for every two new jobs.



By the end of December 2024, nearly 93% of the metro areas monitored in the index had made progress in closing the housing supply gap by increasing the number of single-family building permits issued.

Areas with the Most Severe Housing Shortages:


  • Buffalo-Cheektowaga-Niagara Falls, NY saw the most significant improvement, reducing its housing shortage index by 47.6%. The area went from issuing one permit per 17 new jobs in December 2023 to one permit per nine new jobs in December 2024.
  • New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA experienced a 43% improvement, shifting from one permit per 29 jobs in 2023 to one per 16 in 2024.
  • Other cities with notable improvements include Syracuse, NY (-42.8%), Bridgeport-Stamford-Norwalk, CT (-42.7%), and Champaign-Urbana, IL (-32.9%).


Despite the overall increase in housing supply, 121 metro areas still faced housing shortages by the end of 2024, with indices above the historical average of two.


Metro Areas with the Highest Housing Shortages in Q4 2024:


  • Urban Honolulu, HI had the most significant shortage, with just one permit issued for every 18 new jobs—a 31.9% improvement from the previous year, when the ratio was one permit per 26 jobs.
  • Following closely were New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA (16 jobs per permit) and Miami-Fort Lauderdale-West Palm Beach, FL (14 jobs per permit).
  • Connecticut had three of the top 10 areas with the highest shortage indices: New Haven (14 jobs per permit), Hartford-West Hartford-East Hartford (11 jobs per permit), and Bridgeport-Stamford-Norwalk (9 jobs per permit).
  • Anchorage, AK was the only newcomer to the top 10 list in Q4, issuing one permit for every 10 new jobs.


While all of the top 10 metro areas showed some improvement in housing availability, Anchorage, AK was the exception, seeing its shortage worsen from one permit per eight jobs in December 2023 to one per 10 jobs in December 2024.


Throughout 2024, affordability remained a major challenge in the U.S. housing market, primarily due to low inventory. Metro areas where housing supply was constrained by factors such as labor shortages, limited building permits, or zoning restrictions continued to be unaffordable for many potential buyers. However, as more homes are built, along with job growth and lower mortgage rates, affordability is expected to improve in 2025. NAR forecasts a 2%-3% increase in the median single-family home price in 2025, a more moderate rise compared to the 6% increase seen between December 2023 and December 2024.


For more insights, visit NAR’s Housing Shortage Tracker to see how your area compares.


Citations

Housing Shortage Tracker: Insights from the Final Quarter of 2024

Author: Anat Nusinovich

Published: Feb. 11th, 2025

Blog Link: https://www.nar.realtor/blogs/economists-outlook/housing-shortage-tracker-insights-from-the-final-quarter-of-2024

***NOTE: Housing Shortage Tracker as at the bottom of the page.***

HOUSING SHORTAGE TRACKER

SHARE THIS POST!

MARKET PULSE BLOG


East Tennessee Real Estate Updates, Tri-Cities Auction Insights, and Valuable Market Tips!

Aerial view of houses with green lawns, trees with fall foliage, and a curved road.
By Brandon Keen October 20, 2025
Revive your stale real estate listing with Collins & Company’s professional auction marketing strategies. Fast sales, top value, and seriously qualified buyers.
By Jacob Force October 9, 2025
The recent federal government shutdown has created significant uncertainty in real estate markets nationwide, and East Tennessee is no exception. While our region's housing market has shown remarkable resilience, the ripple effects of a prolonged shutdown could touch local homebuyers, sellers, and the broader economy in ways many residents might not expect. Flood Insurance: An Immediate Concern The most immediate impact stems from the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), which lost its authority to issue new policies when the shutdown began on October 1. This program is critical for East Tennessee, where properties near rivers, creeks, and in flood-prone areas require flood insurance to complete transactions. With an estimated 1,400 property transactions threatened nationwide each day, local buyers and sellers in affected areas could face significant delays or even lost deals. While existing NFIP policies remain valid for 30 days and can be transferred to new owners, the growing uncertainty creates stress for families trying to close on their homes. The longer the lapse continues, the more precarious these situations become. Broader Market Disruptions Beyond flood insurance, government shutdowns typically trigger a cascade of delays that slow the entire real estate process. IRS income verification—essential for mortgage approval—can grind to a halt. FHA and VA loan processing, which many first-time homebuyers and veterans in our region rely on, faces significant backlogs. Federal housing program funding may freeze, affecting affordable housing initiatives in communities throughout East Tennessee. These disruptions hit particularly hard in a market already grappling with affordability challenges and limited inventory. East Tennessee has experienced strong demand and rising home prices in recent years, and any additional friction in the transaction process could sideline buyers who are already stretching their budgets. Economic Impact The stakes extend beyond individual transactions. According to the National Association of Realtors, the NFIP alone supports roughly half a million home sales annually, generating 1 million jobs and contributing $70 billion to the U.S. economy. Housing represents nearly 20% of the national economy, meaning prolonged shutdowns affect not just real estate professionals but contractors, home inspectors, title companies, and countless other businesses that depend on a healthy housing market. For East Tennessee's growing economy, a stable real estate market is essential. Local realtors continue advocating for swift congressional action to reauthorize the NFIP and end the shutdown, ensuring families and businesses can move forward with confidence.
Gavel on US flag and money; symbols of justice and finance.
By Brandon Keen September 26, 2025
Collins & Co. Realtors & Auctioneers leads Elizabethton, TN auctions with expert real estate, estate, farm, auto & specialty auction services.
A couple sits together, looking at a laptop. Boxes are nearby. One holds a mug.
By Brandon Keen August 25, 2025
Avoid costly mistakes when selling your Tri-Cities property. Collins & Co. shares 5 tips to sell faster, smarter, and for the best possible price.
Gavel resting on a stack of money against the backdrop of the American flag.
August 25, 2025
Discover why East Tennessee buyers and sellers choose Collins & Co.’s hybrid real estate marketing. MLS + auctions = faster sales, record land prices.
By Bobbie McMahan August 11, 2025
The real estate market in East Tennessee is currently experiencing strong demand due to the region's desirable living conditions, lower cost of living, and scenic surroundings. As a result, property values are generally on the rise. Factors contributing to this include remote work capability which has prompted a shift towards suburban and rural areas. In turn driving up demand for properties in places like Eastern TN. In addition, a shortage of housing inventory has further fueled the market. Don’t delay. Let Collins and Co. help you find your TN property.
By Jacob Force July 29, 2025
As your local Elizabethton real estate specialist, I'm pleased to share a comprehensive look at how our Carter County market has performed during the first six months of 2025. The data reveals fascinating trends that tell the story of a market finding its balance after years of dramatic changes. A Journey of Market Stabilization Looking back at our market's evolution, Elizabethton has experienced a remarkable transformation. In December 2024, our median home price peaked at $264,000, reflecting the tail end of the pandemic-driven price surge. However, the first half of 2025 tells a different story – one of gradual market correction and stabilization. By February 2025, prices had adjusted to $251,000, and our mid-year data shows we've settled at a year-to-date median of $240,000. This represents a healthy market correction of approximately 9% from the December peak, bringing affordability back to Elizabethton while maintaining strong underlying value. Steady Sales Activity Despite Regional Volatility With 169 homes sold through June 2025, Elizabethton achieved a modest 1.2% increase in sales volume compared to the same period last year. This steady performance is particularly noteworthy given the dramatic swings occurring throughout our region. While some communities like Bluff City saw explosive 95.6% growth and others like Surgoinsville experienced 42.9% declines, Elizabethton maintained consistent buyer activity. This stability aligns with the broader migration patterns identified by Don Fenley, who noted that while "new residents continued flocking to the Tri-Cities," the flow decreased by 30% in 2024. Our steady sales volume suggests Elizabethton continues attracting both local buyers and newcomers seeking value in the region. Regional Value Leader At $240,000, Elizabethton's median price positions our community as an exceptional value proposition. We're significantly below premium markets like Jonesborough ($405,000) and Piney Flats ($425,000), while offering comparable quality of life and access to regional amenities. Even compared to the overall Tri-Cities median of $278,048, Elizabethton provides substantial savings without compromising on community character. Looking Ahead The first half of 2025 demonstrates that Elizabethton's real estate market has successfully navigated the post-pandemic adjustment period. Our modest 0.42% year-over-year price increase indicates we've reached a sustainable equilibrium, offering both buyers and sellers a predictable market environment. For buyers, this represents an excellent opportunity to enter a stabilized market with strong value potential. For sellers, the consistent sales activity and price stability provide confidence in market conditions. As we move into the second half of 2025, Elizabethton's combination of affordability, stability, and regional connectivity positions our community as a smart choice for anyone considering Carter County real estate.
Jacob force is a realtor and auctioneer
By Jacob Force June 19, 2025
Fanatics and the Sports Card Market: A Game-Changing Shift: The sports card industry is experiencing seismic shifts as Fanatics secures exclusive licensing deals with major sports leagues, including the NBA, NFL, and MLB. Starting in 2026, Fanatics will take over card production from longtime industry leaders like Panini and Topps. This transition promises to reshape the collectibles landscape in ways that could dramatically impact card values and collector behavior. Positive Impacts on the Market: Fanatics bring significant advantages to sports card collecting. Their massive distribution network and retail partnerships could make cards more accessible to casual fans, potentially expanding the collector base beyond traditional hobbyists. The company's digital-first approach may introduce innovative features like QR codes linking to exclusive content, enhanced authentication technology, and seamless integration with fantasy sports platforms. Their financial resources dwarf those of current manufacturers, suggesting higher production values, better print quality, and more elaborate insert sets. Fanatics also has direct relationships with athletes through their merchandise deals, potentially creating unique autograph opportunities and exclusive content that previous manufacturers couldn't access. This vertical integration could lead to more authentic, player-driven collectibles. The company's tech-savvy approach may also address long-standing issues like counterfeiting through blockchain authentication and improved quality control processes. Potential Negative Consequences: However, this transition raises serious concerns among collectors. Fanatics lacks the decades of card-making expertise that Panini and Topps have cultivated. Their inexperience could result in design missteps, quality control issues, or products that feel more like corporate merchandise than authentic collectibles. The loss of competition could prove detrimental. Panini and Topps have pushed each other to innovate, creating diverse product lines that cater to different collector segments. A Fanatics monopoly might reduce variety and creativity while potentially increasing prices due to lack of competitive pressure. Established collectors worry about continuity. Long-running sets like Topps Heritage or Panini Prizm have built devoted followings over years. Disrupting these traditions could alienate core collectors who value consistency and heritage. Impact on Card Values: The transition period will likely create volatility in card values. Pre-Fanatics cards from established manufacturers may gain premium status as "final editions," similar to how Upper Deck baseball cards appreciated after losing their MLB license. Conversely, uncertainty about Fanatics' quality and design philosophy could suppress values until their products prove themselves. Long-term value impacts depend entirely on execution. If Fanatics delivers innovative, high-quality products while expanding the market, values could rise substantially. However, if they prioritize mass market appeal over collector-focused features, traditional hobbyists might flee to other sports or alternative collectibles, potentially deflating the entire market. The sports card industry stands at a crossroads, with Fanatics holding the keys to either unprecedented growth or potential disruption of a beloved hobby. If you need help evaluating or liquidating your collection, Please feel free to reach out. We are constantly looking for inventory for our sports card auctions. We market, auction, pack, and ship collectables around the county. Making Collins and Company Realtors and Auctioneers your one stop shop for collectable auctions.
An aerial view of a residential neighborhood with houses and trees.
By Brandon Keen June 18, 2025
Not sure whether to sell your property via auction or traditional listing? Compare both methods and discover which strategy works best for your real estate goals.
A large house with a lush green lawn in front of it.
By Brandon Keen May 16, 2025
Smart Tennessee homebuyers succeed with these proven strategies, expert tips, and step-by-step guide to navigating the East TN real estate market.
More Posts
Collins & Co. Realtor And Auctioneers Logo with MLS #364 - Firm #265789 - P.A.L. #4465

Collins & Co. Realtors And Auctioneers provides comprehensive real estate and auction services. Voted Best Real Estate Agency, Auction Firm, and Realtors by The Johnson Press and The Elizabethton Star Readers' Choice Awards, you can trust our experts to help you achieve your goals. Come see the difference our professional team of auctioneers and real estate agents can make! Contact us to get started today.

Go ahead... We're listening!


(423) 543-5741

collinsandcoinfo@gmail.com


David Collins - Real Estate Broker & Auctioneer

MLS Brokerage #364 - Real Estate Firm #265789 - P.A.L. #4465