Fanatics and the Sports Card Market: A Game-Changing Shift

Jacob Force • June 19, 2025

Fanatics and the Sports Card Market: A Game-Changing Shift:

The sports card industry is experiencing seismic shifts as Fanatics secures exclusive licensing deals with major sports leagues, including the NBA, NFL, and MLB. Starting in 2026, Fanatics will take over card production from longtime industry leaders like Panini and Topps. This transition promises to reshape the collectibles landscape in ways that could dramatically impact card values and collector behavior.


Positive Impacts on the Market:

Fanatics bring significant advantages to sports card collecting. Their massive distribution network and retail partnerships could make cards more accessible to casual fans, potentially expanding the collector base beyond traditional hobbyists. The company's digital-first approach may introduce innovative features like QR codes linking to exclusive content, enhanced authentication technology, and seamless integration with fantasy sports platforms.

Their financial resources dwarf those of current manufacturers, suggesting higher production values, better print quality, and more elaborate insert sets. Fanatics also has direct relationships with athletes through their merchandise deals, potentially creating unique autograph opportunities and exclusive content that previous manufacturers couldn't access. This vertical integration could lead to more authentic, player-driven collectibles.

The company's tech-savvy approach may also address long-standing issues like counterfeiting through blockchain authentication and improved quality control processes.


Potential Negative Consequences:

However, this transition raises serious concerns among collectors. Fanatics lacks the decades of card-making expertise that Panini and Topps have cultivated. Their inexperience could result in design missteps, quality control issues, or products that feel more like corporate merchandise than authentic collectibles.

The loss of competition could prove detrimental. Panini and Topps have pushed each other to innovate, creating diverse product lines that cater to different collector segments. A Fanatics monopoly might reduce variety and creativity while potentially increasing prices due to lack of competitive pressure.

Established collectors worry about continuity. Long-running sets like Topps Heritage or Panini Prizm have built devoted followings over years. Disrupting these traditions could alienate core collectors who value consistency and heritage.


Impact on Card Values:

The transition period will likely create volatility in card values. Pre-Fanatics cards from established manufacturers may gain premium status as "final editions," similar to how Upper Deck baseball cards appreciated after losing their MLB license. Conversely, uncertainty about Fanatics' quality and design philosophy could suppress values until their products prove themselves.

Long-term value impacts depend entirely on execution. If Fanatics delivers innovative, high-quality products while expanding the market, values could rise substantially. However, if they prioritize mass market appeal over collector-focused features, traditional hobbyists might flee to other sports or alternative collectibles, potentially deflating the entire market.

The sports card industry stands at a crossroads, with Fanatics holding the keys to either unprecedented growth or potential disruption of a beloved hobby.

If you need help evaluating or liquidating your collection, Please feel free to reach out. We are constantly looking for inventory for our sports card auctions. We market, auction, pack, and ship collectables around the county. Making Collins and Company Realtors and Auctioneers your one stop shop for collectable auctions. 




SHARE THIS POST!

MARKET PULSE BLOG


East Tennessee Real Estate Updates, Tri-Cities Auction Insights, and Valuable Market Tips!

A person in a suit holds a book and gestures toward a wooden casket decorated with dried wheat, candles, and flowers.
By Brandon Keen March 20, 2026
Learn how North Carolina estate auctions work. Settle an estate faster, maximize value, and explore professional estate auction services in North Carolina.
North Carolina flag over a rural landscape with a farmhouse, golf bag, excavator, tractor, and a gavel on a foreground table.
By Brandon Keen March 20, 2026
Learn how online auctions in North Carolina work. Discover bidding strategies, seller benefits, and why personal property auctions maximize value with Collins & Co.
By Tracy Little March 2, 2026
The winter solstice has passed, and you might have noticed that daylight is gradually beginning to lengthen — with sunset occurring about a minute or two later each day. And in just about two months’ time, we’ll spring ahead to enjoy even more sunlight. In 2026, Daylight Saving Time will begin Sunday, March 8 at 2 a.m., when clocks move forward one hour — jumping from 2 a.m. to 3 a.m. According to The Old Farmer’s Almanac , the purpose of the clock change is to make better use of natural daylight. When clocks “fall back” to standard time, it shifts sunrise earlier — meaning brighter mornings. After the winter solstice on Dec. 21, daylight gradually increases each day, even if mornings still feel dim for a while. And when Daylight Saving Time begins again in March, sunrise and sunset will both occur about one hour later than the day before, giving most people more evening daylight. (ad credit: Jessica Jones-Gorman/SILive.com)
By David Collins March 2, 2026
Why settle for 50% off when you can get full value? Estate liquidators start high and discount — we start at the bottom and let competitive bidding drive prices up. Collins & Company auctions draw from a pool of thousands of local and nationwide bidders, ensuring your estate brings top dollar. Unlike estate liquidators who typically leave 25% of items unsold, our auction model means nearly everything sells — leaving you with little to nothing left over to deal with afterward, and we can even help with that. The auction never stops — accessible online anytime, anywhere. That means bidders from across the country can compete for your items around the clock, driving prices even higher. And there's no guessing — at the end of every auction you receive a complete catalog showing exactly what every item sold for. With years of experience and a trusted reputation, Collins & Company has the knowledge and the reach to get you the results you deserve. Why not give Collins & Company a try? Call today for a free consultation — you have nothing to lose and everything to gain.
By Jacob Force February 26, 2026
The Auctioneer’s Note.... by Jacob Force, Realtor and Auctioneer
By David Collins February 6, 2026
Seller Beware: The Hidden Trap in Unsolicited Property Offers 
Text:
By Jacob Force January 15, 2026
Join Jacob Force - Realtor & Auctioneer as he explores Estate Auctions with Collins & Co. Contact us to start your auction today! (423) 543-5741
By Jacob Force December 16, 2025
The Season of Giving... But Don't Get Scammed The holidays bring out the best in people—generosity, warmth, and community spirit. But unfortunately, this season of giving also attracts those looking to take advantage of trusting homeowners. As Northeast Tennessee Realtors Association President Wayne Porter warns, the region's remodeling boom has created fertile ground for scammers to operate. Our local housing market tells an important story. The average existing home sold in Northeast Tennessee is roughly 44 years old, significantly older than the national median of 36 years. These aging homes need updates, and with limited housing inventory pushing more residents toward remodeling instead of moving, demand for contractors has never been higher. When projects range from $100,000 to $200,000 or more, scammers take notice. The consequences are real. Local cases like the conviction of Joe Wood of Wood Construction and Remodeling, who received 10 months of electronically monitored home detention contingent on full restitution to his victims, demonstrate how devastating contractor fraud can be for families. (For more details, visit https://www.wjhl.com/news/local/wood-construction-owner-gets-10-months-home-detention/ ) Stories of unfinished projects, shoddy workmanship, and broken promises are becoming all too common. Protect yourself by watching for these red flags: No physical office or vague business addresses Refusal to provide licensing or insurance proof Demands for large upfront deposits beyond state limits Unsolicited "discounts" or claims of leftover materials Contractor-arranged financing (often predatory) Suspicious online reviews that seem manufactured No detailed written contract provided Pressure to approve incomplete work While the Tri-Cities area has many reputable, skilled contractors who take pride in their craft, the surge in remodeling demand has attracted less-qualified operators making promises they can't keep. Older homes present unique challenges—outdated wiring, aging plumbing, structural surprises—that require genuine expertise and proper permits. Your best defense is diligence. Take time to verify credentials, check references thoroughly, obtain multiple bids, and read every contract carefully. Don't let holiday excitement or contractor pressure rush you into poor decisions. The National Association of Realtors offers valuable consumer resources at Houselogic.com, including guides on screening contractors and managing renovation projects. Visit https://lookforther.realtor/remodel/ for expert remodeling advice. This season, give yourself the gift of due diligence. A little research now can save you from turning your dream project into a financial nightmare.
Two-story beige house with gray roof, stone accents, two-car garage, and concrete driveway.
By Brandon Keen December 16, 2025
Estate auctions simplify probate by providing a clear, efficient way for Executors to sell property. Learn your options and download our free Executor’s Guide.
By Jacob Force November 4, 2025
Understanding the Shift in Northeast Tennessee's Home Equity Landscape Recent data from ATTOM reveals a subtle but significant shift in Northeast Tennessee's real estate market. According to Don Fenley at Core Data, the number of equity-rich properties in the Tri-Cities declined by 3.6% during the third quarter, while seriously underwater mortgages increased by 0.4%. While these changes may seem modest, they signal an important transition that could affect local homeowners, buyers, and the broader market. What Does "Underwater" Really Mean? A seriously underwater mortgage occurs when a homeowner owes at least 25% more than their property's current market value—a loan-to-value ratio of 125% or higher. Across the Tri-Cities' 86,923 mortgaged properties, certain areas show higher vulnerability. Abingdon's 24210 zip code leads the region with 4.8% of mortgages seriously underwater, followed by nearby 24202 Bristol at 4.7% and 24211 Abingdon at 4.0%. Meanwhile, communities like Elizabethton maintain stronger equity positions, with 60.6% of properties equity-rich. Market Stabilization After Years of Growth Rob Barber, CEO of ATTOM, notes that "after several years of strong equity growth that peaked in 2022, homeowner equity levels appear to be stabilizing." For Northeast Tennessee, this means the rapid appreciation that benefited many homeowners is moderating. The modest fluctuations suggest our housing market is finding balance rather than experiencing crisis. However, this stabilization presents challenges for specific groups. Homeowners who purchased near market peaks or in areas experiencing slower appreciation may find themselves with limited options. Selling becomes difficult when proceeds won't cover the outstanding loan balance. Refinancing to lower interest rates or access cash becomes nearly impossible when underwater. This constraint keeps inventory tight and may prevent families from relocating for job opportunities or life changes. Implications for Buyers and Sellers For prospective buyers, understanding equity distribution across zip codes provides valuable insight. Areas with higher percentages of underwater mortgages may see fewer listings as constrained sellers wait for values to recover. Conversely, communities like Johnson City's 37604, where 59.5% of properties are equity-rich, may offer more inventory as homeowners have flexibility to sell. Current sellers with strong equity positions—the majority in most Tri-Cities communities—remain well-positioned to make moves. However, anyone who purchased in the past two years should carefully evaluate their equity situation before listing. Looking Ahead The increase in underwater mortgages, though still relatively small compared to national trends, warrants attention. Real estate professionals must help clients navigate this evolving landscape with realistic expectations about pricing and timing. The market isn't in distress, but the era of guaranteed rapid appreciation has given way to a more measured environment where location, condition, and pricing strategy matter more than ever.
More Posts
Collins & Co. Realtor And Auctioneers Logo with MLS #364 - Firm #265789 - P.A.L. #4465

Collins & Co. Realtors And Auctioneers provides comprehensive real estate and auction services. Voted Best Real Estate Agency, Auction Firm, and Realtors by The Johnson Press and The Elizabethton Star Readers' Choice Awards, you can trust our experts to help you achieve your goals. Come see the difference our professional team of auctioneers and real estate agents can make! Contact us to get started today.

Go ahead... We're listening!


(423) 543-5741

collinsandcoinfo@gmail.com


David Collins - Real Estate Broker & Auctioneer

MLS Brokerage #364 - Real Estate Firm #265789 - P.A.L. #4465