Fanatics and the Sports Card Market: A Game-Changing Shift
Fanatics and the Sports Card Market: A Game-Changing Shift:
The sports card industry is experiencing seismic shifts as Fanatics secures exclusive licensing deals with major sports leagues, including the NBA, NFL, and MLB. Starting in 2026, Fanatics will take over card production from longtime industry leaders like Panini and Topps. This transition promises to reshape the collectibles landscape in ways that could dramatically impact card values and collector behavior.
Positive Impacts on the Market:
Fanatics bring significant advantages to sports card collecting. Their massive distribution network and retail partnerships could make cards more accessible to casual fans, potentially expanding the collector base beyond traditional hobbyists. The company's digital-first approach may introduce innovative features like QR codes linking to exclusive content, enhanced authentication technology, and seamless integration with fantasy sports platforms.
Their financial resources dwarf those of current manufacturers, suggesting higher production values, better print quality, and more elaborate insert sets. Fanatics also has direct relationships with athletes through their merchandise deals, potentially creating unique autograph opportunities and exclusive content that previous manufacturers couldn't access. This vertical integration could lead to more authentic, player-driven collectibles.
The company's tech-savvy approach may also address long-standing issues like counterfeiting through blockchain authentication and improved quality control processes.
Potential Negative Consequences:
However, this transition raises serious concerns among collectors. Fanatics lacks the decades of card-making expertise that Panini and Topps have cultivated. Their inexperience could result in design missteps, quality control issues, or products that feel more like corporate merchandise than authentic collectibles.
The loss of competition could prove detrimental. Panini and Topps have pushed each other to innovate, creating diverse product lines that cater to different collector segments. A Fanatics monopoly might reduce variety and creativity while potentially increasing prices due to lack of competitive pressure.
Established collectors worry about continuity. Long-running sets like Topps Heritage or Panini Prizm have built devoted followings over years. Disrupting these traditions could alienate core collectors who value consistency and heritage.
Impact on Card Values:
The transition period will likely create volatility in card values. Pre-Fanatics cards from established manufacturers may gain premium status as "final editions," similar to how Upper Deck baseball cards appreciated after losing their MLB license. Conversely, uncertainty about Fanatics' quality and design philosophy could suppress values until their products prove themselves.
Long-term value impacts depend entirely on execution. If Fanatics delivers innovative, high-quality products while expanding the market, values could rise substantially. However, if they prioritize mass market appeal over collector-focused features, traditional hobbyists might flee to other sports or alternative collectibles, potentially deflating the entire market.
The sports card industry stands at a crossroads, with Fanatics holding the keys to either unprecedented growth or potential disruption of a beloved hobby.
If you need help evaluating or liquidating your collection, Please feel free to reach out. We are constantly looking for inventory for our sports card auctions. We market, auction, pack, and ship collectables around the county. Making Collins and Company Realtors and Auctioneers your one stop shop for collectable auctions.
SHARE THIS POST!
MARKET PULSE BLOG
East Tennessee Real Estate Updates, Tri-Cities Auction Insights, and Valuable Market Tips!



Collins & Co. Realtors And Auctioneers provides comprehensive real estate and auction services. Voted Best Real Estate Agency, Auction Firm, and Realtors by The Johnson Press and The Elizabethton Star Readers' Choice Awards, you can trust our experts to help you achieve your goals. Come see the difference our professional team of auctioneers and real estate agents can make! Contact us to get started today.
Go ahead... We're listening!
David Collins - Real Estate Broker & Auctioneer
MLS Brokerage #364 - Real Estate Firm #265789 - P.A.L. #4465